Joint Operations Map Discussion

[Murkey]

How about this for next week:
Qwai AAS STD

Xiangshan AAS STD

Silent Eagel AAS ALT

Nice suggestions. We'd need to swap the teams between Qwai and Xiangshan to avoid double China. I also think Silent Eagle is a bit too similar to Xiangshan. I'd consider other 4km maps like Black Gold or Khamisiyah.

GG's yesterday (nice inf fighting in the city of burning sands, the taliban did very well on kokan but then we lost it on Saaremaa).

Cheers, Murkey.

[Tankbuster]

I also think it is best to put the heavy asset map in the middle, as you need a full team for them. Xiangshan can be played with less people

[Blackpanther]

Well we had Black Gold this week so we should either play kamishia or kashan

[WeeD-KilleR]

Well we had 4km² desert this week so we should either play 4km² desert or 4km² desert

[[ODG]Rabbit]

Hades Peak -Infantry
Muttrah -Large
Wanda -Standard

All very balanced layers according to our stat tracker and no repeat factions.

\Thread

[i-kill-you2]

We played hades and wanda 2 weeks ago

[Blackpanther]

Well we had 4km² desert this week so we should either play 4km² desert or 4km² desert

Ok first of all lets list up the 4km² maps we have:

Back Gold played in the last 3 weeks
Wanda played in the last 3 weeks
Sarema played in the last 3 weeks
Hades played in the last 3 weeks
Yamlia played in the last 3 weeks
Bijar played in the last 3 weeks

this leaves us with Xiangshan, Vadso and Silent according to murkey Xiangshan and Silent are quite similiar to each other and I would count Vadso in aswell, so the only 3 Maps that are left are Desert maps: Burning, Kami, Kashan.

And your comment doesn't make any sense since it is saying that we shouldn't play a 4km² desert map since we had one last week, according to your statment there shouldn't be a 4km² woodland map this week since we had one last week.
Furthermore I would Black Gold INF rather count as an urban since all the fight is happening in the streets.

[Norby]

I dont get this discussion. Why do we have to play 4k? Why is it illegal to play a map which has been played in the last weeks? Also you forgot Pavlovsk.

Hades Peak -Infantry
Muttrah -Large
Wanda -Standard

All very balanced layers according to our stat tracker and no repeat factions.

\Thread

I still wonder how Wanda STD is balanced in your stats. I have only once seen chinese win this. And in that case the ch team was stacked and the ger CAS pilots sucked, so the Z9 could take care of the Leopard problem. All the other times I played STD the Leopards just killed everything and chinese lost. 3 vs 1 tank does not work. ATGM can only kill one and the other 2 will kill you before you reload. Even 2 vs 1 (Shijia) is in favor of the 2 tank team.

On LRG china has an advantage but its not that significant. INF is cool, the better team is going to win.

[Blackpanther]

Richtig pavlovsk....
So: Qwai AAS STD
Shijia AAS LRG or INF?
Silent AAS ALT

[Murkey]

OK we're running out of time again, if we want to post a maplist before the event, unlike last week.

So lets concentrate on compromise and building consensus.

Blackpanther suggests:
Qwai AAS STD
Shijia AAS LRG or INF?
Silent AAS ALT

Rabbit suggests:
Hades Peak -INF
Muttrah -LRG
Wanda -STD

Some maps have been played recently, but I think as long as we have a decent mix and are sure to play a few under-represented maps then it's ok. To be honest neither list sets my heart ablaze. I'm not sure about going from Shijia (especially large) to Silent Eagle, as an infantry player, I think it could end up being pretty slow, so a urban or desert map would seem more fitting, although there is always a map vote and more games to be had. As for Rabbits suggestions, again, not bad, I just don't really like Hades, just a personal thing.

Sooo..... TL;DR - both good suggestions.

Questions - any more, constructive discussion to be had? Otherwise who makes the final decision? Who will be posting the map list? I wanted to post something last week, when nothing was decided, but didn't want to overstep my mark.

Cheers, Murkey.