Mapdiscussion and choice

[TriPPLe_XxX_[GER]]

BTW Kozelsk = 1 shot bug
and Shijia and kozelsk we had alreadey on an JFTD before i guess or ?

[K4on]

maps should be choosen more democratic tbh.

every week a poll for maps, rules are that maps (except "special event" maps) cant be be played twice a months. we will discuss this at stammtisch.

[Rage]

Yamalia AAS STD
Iron Ridge AAS STD
Vadso AAS ALT(no CAS)/ STD (CAS on both sides)

BTW Kozelsk = 1 shot bug
and Shijia and kozelsk we had alreadey on an JFTD before i guess or ?

First of all you suggested Iron Ridge AAS STD = 1 shot bug
Second we never played Kozelsk on JFTD before guessing means not knowing!
Third get you facts straight before flaming dont start to bitch around you copycat of "an atom"!
Fourth you will always have at least one who doesnt like a democratic decision if its not 100% for one side and at least one who starts to whine congrats this time its you! Get a cookie!

maps should be choosen more democratic tbh.

every week a poll for maps, rules are that maps (except "special event" maps) cant be be played twice a months. we will discuss this at stammtisch.

Im not the one who decides which maps we will play if this impression is created here. But I am the one who tries to find a consent between sometimes 2 suggestions and sometimes 10. Good luck in doing a vote of 40 maps with different layers every week among 8 voters, will be totaly representative....not!

But maybe we can give a preslection of maps we will discuss that at our regulars' table although honestly its faster and easier like it is atm!

Btw who choses the preselection then?

[K4on]

Its not pointing at you, just a general suggestion of how to give less played maps a chance to get choosen and to make voting more democratic, as quite a few people rather tend to vote for their map in a poll than discussing it with posts.

[i-kill-you2]

Lets take 5 random maps (No maps players posted here)
And make a vote between them.

I agree With k4ons suggestion that we shouldnt play maps twice a month.

Maybe we should give players wich were comander and did a great job something like a reward.
Any suggestions what they could get?
Maybe a Reserved slot for a week or an asset sqad they would like to have the following round.

[fecht_niko]

@ tripple: first think twice before writing...

@ ikillyou2: most of the players have a reserved slot, so i agree more with k4ons suggestion to have commanders of each community/clan

@ k4on: I think we have atm a "good and fast" way of map decision and I dont think that rage is choosing on his own... underplayed maps should be suggested and discussed if they are fun/balanced and mixed with "other terrain maps".

[Neander]

I will create a better overview about the maps we already played in the last JFTDs and add this to the startpost. So we can discuss about the next maps even better

[Ranzpirat]

While I would have liked a real map-votinpoll each week I see no real issue with the way we discuss maps right now.

Not playing a map again if there are other maps which have not been played once before is a good way to determine what to suggest next.

And I realy appreciate Rages posts to "sum up" the discussion and force us to take a decision BEFORE THURSDAY.

Good thing, Neander! That will bring more light into the darkness.

Last words for this post: More inf and alt layouts would be my wish too. A good old assetmashup once in a while is okay, but most of the time we sould focus on good infatery-teamwork and SUPPORTING assetsquads.

[fecht_niko]

Ok lets start:

1. Operation Ghosttrain STD AAS (small Map with only 1 APC, underplayed)
2. Xiangshan STD AAS
3. Beirut (IDF has Scopes with the update) Which layout is balanced ALT or STD?

[Neander]

Beirut:
STD = Only RUS has CAS
ALT = No CAS
LRG = Booth has CAS